Real Estate vs. Stock Market


The Value Appreciation of Residential Real Estate in Germany: Dream vs. Reality

When it comes to building wealth, many Germans instinctively turn to real estate. Buying a home is often seen as a safe and profitable long-term investment. However, a detailed look at the data tells a different story—one that challenges the common belief in ever-increasing property values.

This analysis, based on long-term historical data, reveals that residential real estate in Germany has shown only marginal real (inflation-adjusted) price appreciation over the past five decades.

Long-Term Real Value Growth: A Mere 0.1% per Year

Between 1970 and 2023, real residential property prices in Germany rose by an average of just 0.1% per year. That means that, after accounting for inflation, German residential real estate barely increased in value over more than 50 years.

This figure contrasts sharply with the perception held by many Germans that real estate “always goes up in value.” While nominal prices (those not adjusted for inflation) have indeed increased, most of those gains were absorbed by inflation. As a result, the real purchasing power of property owners barely grew.


Real Estate vs. Stock Market

Start creating wealth!

Get professional and objective advice about your finances.


The Exception: 2010–2021 Real Estate Boom

From 2010 to 2021, Germany experienced a pronounced housing boom. During this period, property prices surged due to historically low interest rates, urbanization trends, and high demand in major cities like Berlin, Munich, and Hamburg.

However, this period was an outlier rather than the norm. It followed a prolonged phase of stagnation and even decline: from 1970 to 2009, real housing prices decreased by an average of 0.4% per year. This earlier decline offset much of the more recent gains.

This pattern reflects a common phenomenon in asset markets called mean reversion: unusually strong growth periods tend to be followed by weaker ones (and vice versa). Over the long run, prices tend to return to their historical averages.

Germany in International Comparison

Germany’s real estate market also lags behind many other developed countries. In a comparative study of 13 Western countries, Germany ranked last with an average real property appreciation of 0.3% per year. Even Japan, known for its long-term economic stagnation and deflation, slightly outperformed Germany with 0.4% per year in real estate appreciation.

This data suggests that Germany’s residential property market has historically underperformed on a global scale.

The Investor’s Takeaway: Caution Over Optimism

For investors considering residential real estate in Germany, the key message is clear: expecting high long-term value appreciation is not supported by historical evidence. While there are individual cases and locations that defy the average, the overall trend suggests caution.

Rather than banking on rising property values, investors should shift their focus toward rental yields and ongoing cash flows, which offer more reliable returns over time. Property should be evaluated primarily for its income-generating potential, not its speculative appreciation.

Final Thoughts

Real estate can still be a valuable component of a diversified portfolio. However, in the German context, its role should be seen more as a source of stable rental income than as a vehicle for rapid capital gains.

Before committing to a property purchase, especially as an investment, it’s worth consulting unbiased data and considering alternative investment strategies—such as diversified portfolios of low-cost index funds or professionally managed active funds.

For those interested in a deeper dive, we recommend reading the original German article by Gerd Kommer and Maximilian Bartosch:
👉 Wertsteigerungen von Wohnimmobilien – Traum und Wirklichkeit